Authors, Writers, Publishers, and Book Readers
Hello...I'm new to the group and wanted to post the beginning of chapter 1 of my book "Tribulation" in hopes that I could get some feedback. All criticism is welcome. I want to make this the best I can. Thank you to all who reply.
Chapter 1
The Beginning
Tags:
Hi I'm into development editing as well as copy & line edits. I work on my own writing pieces. There is a lot of work needed on your opening chapter.
But what amazes me is the number of people who view and pass no comment. I can only assume they are doing things correctly and have no desire to learn about not being published.
To aim at 'not being published' is very easy. Do not reciprocate. Always EXPECT your own work to be read and NEVER read another writer's work. Is that easy or not? 49 people so far are finding it easy. Strange that.
If you'd like me to scan what you've written and pass some comment let me know. I can let you know in private if you add me to your friends list.
There might be a delay when I answer but, no matter. I walked up the road to visit a friend and picked up a novel to read a young Polish lady had written. She has suggested she reads my novel Part 1 if I read her novel. Seems a fair exchange.
Now if I reviewed your work what would you read to reciprocate. I have one writer's work in mind. Not mine. But reading that might teach you something especially if you do a written review and post it to me.
I think it is fair because unless you read it is impossible to write. The two go hand in hand.
Questions:
Who is your mentor?
Who gives you advice?
If you are writing a novel what can a short story possibly tell you?
Have you written any short stories?
Thanks for your reply, I will send you a PM as soon as you accept my friend request.
Your first paragraph -> "A convoy barreled down the dirt road pitching a cloud of dust behind it. Two guards standing at the gate entrance, pulled their rifles to the ready awaiting the oncoming visitors. The Humvee in the lead, braked to a stop in front of the guards as the driver threw his arm out the window flashing his I.D. Immediately, the guards ran to the gate and opened it. Three vehicles drove through the entrance down a maintenance road to the back of an old factory building. As the dust settled, the soldiers from the two Humvees surrounded a black limousine that had been driving between them. The door to the limo opened and two men stepped out; one in a black suit and the other in a white trench coat carrying a metal briefcase handcuffed to his wrist." <- has a few problems. 'pitching' a cloud of dust - not the best word choice for this picture. So the convoy is throwing handfuls of dust up into the air. Try 'stirring up' or 'trailed by' or 'marked by'. -> 'pulled' their rifles to the ready <- as guards, they should always have their rifles ready. Perhaps have them stand up and take notice or even point (with a hand) and then move to block the road. -> the driver threw his arm out the window <- Did he really??? Ouch!!! Better to say he flashed his ID at the guards.
Watch HOW you say things and make sure it paints the picture you want. Try to make your writing unmistakable. You want your reader to understand YOUR picture far more often than anything they might come up with by mistake.
Thanks for the input...I see what you mean. There's a lot of work I need to do on it...It's only a first draft. I was just trying to see what direction I might need to go with it per advice from other authors.
Thanks so much for taking the time to reply.
Anna L. Walls said:
Your first paragraph -> "A convoy barreled down the dirt road pitching a cloud of dust behind it. Two guards standing at the gate entrance, pulled their rifles to the ready awaiting the oncoming visitors. The Humvee in the lead, braked to a stop in front of the guards as the driver threw his arm out the window flashing his I.D. Immediately, the guards ran to the gate and opened it. Three vehicles drove through the entrance down a maintenance road to the back of an old factory building. As the dust settled, the soldiers from the two Humvees surrounded a black limousine that had been driving between them. The door to the limo opened and two men stepped out; one in a black suit and the other in a white trench coat carrying a metal briefcase handcuffed to his wrist." <- has a few problems. 'pitching' a cloud of dust - not the best word choice for this picture. So the convoy is throwing handfuls of dust up into the air. Try 'stirring up' or 'trailed by' or 'marked by'. -> 'pulled' their rifles to the ready <- as guards, they should always have their rifles ready. Perhaps have them stand up and take notice or even point (with a hand) and then move to block the road. -> the driver threw his arm out the window <- Did he really??? Ouch!!! Better to say he flashed his ID at the guards.
Watch HOW you say things and make sure it paints the picture you want. Try to make your writing unmistakable. You want your reader to understand YOUR picture far more often than anything they might come up with by mistake.
Follow your muse. Enjoy the ride. It can be quite surprising sometimes.
Rockella Renee said:
Thanks for the input...I see what you mean. There's a lot of work I need to do on it...It's only a first draft. I was just trying to see what direction I might need to go with it per advice from other authors.
Thanks so much for taking the time to reply.
Anna L. Walls said:
Your first paragraph -> "A convoy barreled down the dirt road pitching a cloud of dust behind it. Two guards standing at the gate entrance, pulled their rifles to the ready awaiting the oncoming visitors. The Humvee in the lead, braked to a stop in front of the guards as the driver threw his arm out the window flashing his I.D. Immediately, the guards ran to the gate and opened it. Three vehicles drove through the entrance down a maintenance road to the back of an old factory building. As the dust settled, the soldiers from the two Humvees surrounded a black limousine that had been driving between them. The door to the limo opened and two men stepped out; one in a black suit and the other in a white trench coat carrying a metal briefcase handcuffed to his wrist." <- has a few problems. 'pitching' a cloud of dust - not the best word choice for this picture. So the convoy is throwing handfuls of dust up into the air. Try 'stirring up' or 'trailed by' or 'marked by'. -> 'pulled' their rifles to the ready <- as guards, they should always have their rifles ready. Perhaps have them stand up and take notice or even point (with a hand) and then move to block the road. -> the driver threw his arm out the window <- Did he really??? Ouch!!! Better to say he flashed his ID at the guards.
Watch HOW you say things and make sure it paints the picture you want. Try to make your writing unmistakable. You want your reader to understand YOUR picture far more often than anything they might come up with by mistake.
OMG! The truth is out there. 'Writing is hard.' And yet we still do it.
What does that tell you?
Keep writing, have fun.
Rockella Renee said:
Thanks for your reply...
The opening paragraph pulls me in. Nice work!
"I have both the knowledge and the means, so why not just take it all?" he reasoned. Who is he talking to here?
The two men were escorted down the sidewalk to a side entrance of the factory. Alone, they marched into the building...Here you say they were escorted by someone, but in the next sentence you say they were alone, I think you need to identify why they went on alone, what happened to the escort?
Sometimes you and use (and) to pull together sentences to eliminate (He) and or the name. Thus not using so many he's...
The story is interesting and fun. I know it is the first draft. Try to stay away from (to be) verbs.
When you bring up new characters and locations, spend some time developing them. Remember this is a book! You will write 70-90 thousand words, which sounds like a lot, but (The instead of a) time will go by fast.
Keep writing and keep asking questions. Please know that not all advise is going to work for you. Take what you want and disregard the rest.
I forgot something, Numbers...The rule is zero through nine are written as numbers, ten and above are written in word form. That doesn't mean you can't use numbers. Just a thought!
I've heard it the other way around, Robert. However, I've never seen numbers as numbers except in a math book, unless you're talking numbers up in the thousands and above, and I've seen very few of those.
Rockella,
I see Anna is back and so is Robert.
Guess now we are in good company.
Thank you all for your encouragement and criticisms...I appreciate you input. I'm working on my revision right now. I am eager to apply the advice I've been given.
I look forward to more discussions with all of you.
Thanks again.
I'm never far, Cleveland, just crunched for time for the summer.
Rockella, I'm happy to help any way I can.
© 2024 Created by Authors.com. Powered by